ProblemFirst.io
Back to Home
Case Study5 min readNovember 5, 2025

How Dollar Shave Club Found a $1B Idea on Reddit

ProblemFirst Team
Community Analysis Experts

The Billion Dollar Insight

Before Dollar Shave Club became a household name, the shaving industry was dominated by giants like Gillette and Schick. These companies were locked in an arms race of adding more blades and increasing prices. But on Reddit and other forums, a different conversation was happening.

Listening to the Noise

Men weren't asking for more blades. They were complaining about the cost. Thread after thread on r/frugal and r/mensgrooming discussed the absurdity of paying $20 for a pack of razor cartridges. The pain point wasn't "I need a closer shave" – it was "I feel ripped off every time I buy razors."

The Value Proposition

Michael Dubin, the founder of Dollar Shave Club, recognized this disconnect. He didn't invent a new technology; he just solved the specific pain point people were screaming about: price and convenience. By offering a subscription service for simple, high-quality razors at a fraction of the cost, he directly addressed the market's frustration.

The Viral Launch

Their launch video directly poked fun at the "shaving tech" features that established brands were pushing, validating the feelings of millions of consumers who felt the major brands were out of touch. It went viral because it resonated with the exact sentiment found in those online discussions.

Key Takeaways for Founders

  • Look for complaints, not just feature requests. The biggest opportunities often come from what people hate about current solutions.
  • Validate sentiment across communities. If multiple subreddits are complaining about the same thing, you've found a gold mine.
  • Address the emotional core. DSC didn't just sell razors; they sold the feeling of not being taken advantage of.